Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 7, 2008

Theory of satisfaction vs perfection in practice... China painting


One of the reasons - actually the main reason - I'm here at my parents' house is because my mom signed up for a 3 day china painting workshop with Paula Collins in Morton, IL, and she needed someone to drive and help her while she was there.

Mom used to do a lot of china painting... before the knee surgeries, pulmonary embolism, etc mentioned in the previous post. All of the medical problems she's had in the past 5 years have managed to set her back in a big way. She's done very little painting, and the shake in her hands has become more pronounced during those difficult years as well. So this workshop has been extremely frustrating and somewhat humiliating for her.

I've been recruited to do some of the painting... a lot of the painting... and to say I am out of my element and out of practice as well is an understatement. Sure, I got my degree in studio art. In 1980. I rarely pick up a brush as small as is used in china painting any more.

So I repeated my mantra as "we" were painting (mom watching, me painting) that the reason we take a class is to learn something new... that we can't expect a masterpiece to come out of it (read: a plate like the instructor's). It's so interesting... in all of the china painting classes I've observed, it's standard practice for the instructor to come around and sort of help "clean up" what the students have done, unless they object (few do). Thinking back, I guess I did a little of that myself when I was teaching polymer clay...

Anyway, here is the teacher's plate progression today (click on photos to enlarge)




And here is "our" plate. I sketched in some leaves after this, but we had to leave because mom was not feeling well, so the teacher blocked them in for us. I'll take a picture tomorrow to show what it looks like fired. The china paints look very different once they are fired...

Sunday, October 5, 2008

Perfection VS Satisfaction

I'm at my parents' house, once again, to help out with getting the folks from one place to the other... and the ride here gave me time to think about perfection and satisfaction.

What should we be striving for, in life, in our art work, in our studies, in all of our endeavors? Is it perfection? Or is it satisfaction?

Some may say perfection. After all, it's a lofty goal, isn't it? Is there anyone who would deny that those who appear to achieve perfection are revered? A perfect test score, a perfect game, a flawless sculpture, a vaccine that would prevent cancer of all kinds, world peace (okay, it's starting to sound like a Miss America pageant... hey, the perfectly proportioned body!) are all wishes, dreams, ideals.

And then, when perfection is achieved... we are satisfied, right? I wonder.

Our son is an excellent student. An all around good person: caring, loving, diligent. Often as not, he achieves that perfect score we all dream of on his exams. He completes all of his homework, often a week ahead of schedule. Is he satisfied?

He worries all the time that he will not live up to expectations. Whose? Not ours. His teachers'? His own? He strives to be perfect, and we try to tell him that perfection is not necessary. Less than perfect is just fine. Work hard and do your best and don't sweat it. Enjoy the ride.

My mother is in pain. She wants her body to be back to the way it was before she had 3 knee surgeries and one partial hip replacement done by an incompetent surgeon, before her pulmonary embolism. She wants to be able to do the things she did before she had the full hip replacement by a competent surgeon, before the vascular surgery on her leg, before 2 extended stays at nursing homes where she was confused and miserable... before her shoulder began aching continuously. So, she goes to doctor after doctor asking them to fix it. Nothing less than perfection will do.

And I have friends who have trouble making things because someone else already does it better. Frankly, I've been there, afraid to put myself out there because my work is not perfect, is not as good as someone else's.

Well, I'm thinking that satisfaction is what we should be looking for. I'm not saying we shouldn't work towards improvement and doing the best we can when we strive to create, or compete, or learn something new. But at some point we should be looking at how satisfying the endeavor is.

You take a class, you learn a new skill, you take a few steps in a walker... you're offered praise, you enjoy the results, you rejoice in what you can do, satisfied in the process.

I'm thinking that perfection is overrated. I'm going to try to revel in my imperfection. That's my goal, now. Satisfaction in each day, in each new attempt. I'll let you know if it works...